Skip to content

Backfill · 2024

#178 of 363

Obsidian vs Notion vs Apple Notes

seq 11
PragmatistComparison/connoisseurshiptechpositive
digital experiencehabit behavior
NoticingWho to Listen ToActionExplore4/9
ObsidianNotionApple Notes
ImageEditorial/lifestyle

Editorial lifestyle photo showing 3 laptop screens side by side, each displaying a different note-taking app: Obsidian with its graph view, Notion with a database page, and Apple Notes with a simple text list.

417 words

Obsidian, Notion, and Apple Notes represent 3 fundamentally different approaches to organizing your thoughts and information. Which one you prefer says a lot about how your brain processes ideas. Obsidian stores everything as plain Markdown files on your local drive. Your notes are yours forever, not dependent on a company's servers staying online. The linking system lets you connect notes to each other and visualize the connections as a graph. It appeals to people who think in networks and associations rather than hierarchies. Notion structures everything in databases and pages that support rich formatting, embedded media, and collaboration. The flexibility is both its strength and its weakness. You can spend more time designing your workspace than actually using it. Templates are powerful but the learning curve is steep. I've watched friends build elaborate Notion setups in September that they abandon by November because the maintenance overhead exceeds the organizational benefit. Apple Notes is the opposite extreme. Bare-bones: just text, images, and checklists. It syncs across devices without configuration. The limitation is the advantage. You open it, type, and close it. The note is there on your phone and your laptop without you thinking about file formats or database structures. However, you can't link notes to each other, the search is basic, and there is no tagging system. Once you have 500 notes, the lack of structure becomes its own problem. After using all 3, I settled on Obsidian for long-form thinking and Apple Notes for quick captures. That combination covers my use cases without Notion's overhead. Around Obsidian, the community is the most active of the 3, with a plugin marketplace that adds kanban boards, calendar views, and citation managers. Extensibility keeps the tool relevant as your needs change. But the best note app is the one you actually open every day. For most people, that's whichever one requires the least friction between having a thought and recording it. Cost breakdown is simple: Obsidian is free for personal use, Notion is free with a generous tier, and Apple Notes is free if you own an Apple device. None of them charge enough to make price a differentiating factor.